The Role of Customary Law in Marriages and Divorce Cases in Kenya

Quote

Kenya’s legal framework for marriage and divorce is a complex interplay of statutory, customary, religious, and common law systems, reflecting the country’s diverse cultural heritage. The Marriage Act, 2014, is the primary legislation governing marriage in Kenya, consolidating various marriage regimes, including customary marriages. This article explores the recognition of customary marriages, such as those under Luo or Kikuyu law, under the Marriage Act, 2014, and their implications for divorce proceedings. It also examines the challenges and considerations that arise when customary law interfaces with statutory law in Kenyan family law matters.

Recognition of Customary Marriages Under the Marriage Act, 2014

The Marriage Act, 2014, recognizes five types of marriage in Kenya: civil, Christian, Islamic, Hindu, and customary marriages. Section 3(1) of the Act defines a customary marriage as one celebrated in accordance with the customs of the communities of one or both parties to the marriage. This provision ensures that marriages conducted under traditional practices, such as those of the Luo, Kikuyu, Luhya, Kamba, or other Kenyan ethnic groups, are legally valid, provided they meet certain requirements.

Requirements for a Valid Customary Marriage

For a customary marriage to be recognized under the Marriage Act, 2014, it must comply with the customs of the relevant community and statutory requirements.

Key aspects include:

  1. Compliance with Customary Rites: The marriage must follow the specific rituals and practices of the community. For example:

    • Kikuyu Customary Marriage: Known as Ngurario, it involves payment of dowry (referred to as ruracio), negotiations between families, and ceremonies that signify the union. The dowry may include livestock, money, or other items, and its payment is a critical element of validity.

    • Luo Customary Marriage: Referred to as Doho, it involves dowry payment (often called chulo dhoch), family negotiations, and traditional ceremonies. Consent of the bride and groom, as well as family involvement, is essential.

  2. Consent and Capacity: Section 11 of the Marriage Act requires that both parties freely consent to the marriage and have the capacity to marry (e.g., they must be at least 18 years old and not already in a monogamous marriage).

  3. Registration: Section 44 mandates that all customary marriages be registered within six months of the ceremony. Couples must apply to the Registrar of Marriages, providing evidence of the marriage, such as affidavits or witnesses. Failure to register does not invalidate the marriage but may complicate legal recognition in disputes, such as divorce or inheritance cases.

  4. Monogamy or Polygamy: Customary marriages are often polygamous, which is permissible under the Act (Section 6(3)) unless the marriage is converted to a monogamous union. For instance, a Kikuyu or Luo man may marry multiple wives under customary law, provided each marriage adheres to the community’s customs.

Legal Recognition and Implications

The recognition of customary marriages under the Marriage Act, 2014, grants them equal status to other marriage regimes in terms of legal protections, such as inheritance rights, property division, and child custody. However, the integration of customary law into a statutory framework presents challenges, particularly in proving the existence of a marriage. Courts often require evidence of customary rites, such as dowry payment or witness testimonies, to establish validity. For example, the court will uphold a customary marriage based on evidence of dowry payment and family involvement, despite the lack of registration.

Customary Law and Divorce Proceedings

Divorce under customary law varies significantly from statutory divorce processes, and the interaction between the two systems can be complex. The Marriage Act, 2014, governs divorce for all marriage types, including customary marriages, but customary practices often influence proceedings, especially in out-of-court settlements.

Divorce Under Customary Law

Customary divorce procedures depend on the community’s traditions:

  • Kikuyu Customary Divorce: Divorce, though rare, may occur through mutual agreement or due to specific grounds, such as infidelity, barrenness, or cruelty. The process often involves family elders and may require the return of dowry (fully or partially) to the husband’s family. The Kikuyu traditionally prioritize reconciliation, and divorce is seen as a last resort.

  • Luo Customary Divorce: Divorce is also uncommon but may be initiated for reasons like desertion or failure to fulfill marital obligations. Elders mediate, and dowry repayment may be negotiated. In some cases, a wife may return to her natal home, signaling the end of the marriage.

These customary processes are not legally binding under the Marriage Act, but they are often pursued before or alongside statutory divorce proceedings, especially in rural areas.

Statutory Divorce for Customary Marriages

Under the Marriage Act, 2014, divorce for customary marriages is governed by Sections 66–71. The Act requires that divorce petitions be filed in court, with grounds including:

  • Adultery

  • Cruelty

  • Desertion for at least three years

  • Irretrievable breakdown of the marriage

Courts apply these statutory grounds uniformly, but customary practices may influence the proceedings. For instance:

  1. Evidence of Marriage: To grant a divorce, the court must first confirm the existence of a valid customary marriage. This may involve proving dowry payment, ceremonies, or cohabitation. In M.W. v. J.K. [2017], a Kikuyu customary marriage was recognized based on ruracio payment, allowing the divorce to proceed.

  2. Dowry Considerations: While courts do not enforce dowry repayment, parties may negotiate dowry refunds as part of out-of-court settlements, reflecting customary norms. For example, in Luo divorces, the wife’s family may return part of the dowry to avoid disputes.

  3. Child Custody and Maintenance: Customary law often prioritizes paternal custody (e.g., among the Luo, children traditionally belong to the father’s clan). However, courts apply the Children Act, 2001, which emphasizes the best interests of the child, often overriding customary norms.

  4. Property Division: The Matrimonial Property Act, 2013, governs property division, but customary law may influence perceptions of ownership. For instance, in Kikuyu custom, property acquired during marriage is often considered the husband’s, but courts may order equitable division based on contributions.

Challenges in Divorce Proceedings

The interplay between customary and statutory law creates several challenges:

  • Conflict of Laws: Customary divorce practices, such as dowry repayment or elder mediation, are not recognized by courts, leading to tension between community expectations and legal requirements.

  • Proof of Marriage: Unregistered customary marriages can complicate divorce proceedings, as parties must provide evidence of customary rites.

  • Cultural Sensitivities: Courts must balance respect for cultural practices with statutory obligations, particularly in polygamous marriages or cases involving dowry disputes.

  • Access to Justice: Many Kenyans, especially in rural areas, rely on customary dispute resolution due to limited access to courts, which may delay or undermine statutory divorce processes.

Conclusion

Customary marriages, such as those under Luo or Kikuyu law, are integral to Kenya’s legal and cultural landscape, and their recognition under the Marriage Act, 2014, ensures that traditional practices coexist with statutory law. However, the interaction between customary and statutory systems in divorce proceedings can be fraught with challenges, including conflicts over dowry, property, and child custody. To navigate these complexities, parties to customary marriages should seek legal advice to ensure compliance with both customary and statutory requirements.

Contact us today at +254 716 708 104 or info@lawguide.co.ke for expert advice.